Paddling in Organizational Whitewater: Is it Technical Skills or Wisdom that you Need to Lead?
There’s no shortage of advice from the self-appointed experts and countless writers on leadership. Everyone has their own angle or perspective. The purpose of this post is to zoom in on one particular aspect of leading people during what can be described as organizational whitewater. I’ll use one analogy as an illustration.
First, however, let’s look at how new university graduates from business schools have been set up for failure as leaders when they enter the real world. While a few management writers over the past few years have noted this problem, McGill University management guru Henry Mintzberg has consistently hammered away at it.
Management and leadership are intertwined. Mintzberg explains that leaders cannot be “trained” in MBA programs; it comes only with experience – falling down, picking yourself up, learning from the experience, and then moving forward.
What has occurred in the business world is that new grads don’t possess the contextual knowledge and life experiences to handle complex problems. Yes, they’ve acquired technical skills and a foundation for building their careers, but to say that they’re ready for dealing effectively with inter-related issues affecting, for example, suppliers, customer needs, unions, staff relationships, foreign partners, and production schedules is unrealistic.
One of Mintzberg’s big beefs with business schools is their heavy reliance on the use of case studies. This artificial reality in his view gives graduates a false sense of capability. Learning through experience is what counts. I’ll provide an analogy that will help drive home Mintzberg’s point.In my younger years (30s and 40s) I was very heavy into outdoor recreation. One activity I loved was whitewater canoeing (I tried kayaking but didn’t like it as much). I was fortunate to have excellent instructors, fellows in the 40s, who had been paddling for over 20 years. They were masters at what they did. It was inspiring to watch them navigate whitewater, displaying not just power but more importantly grace and wisdom. It’s not about brute strength when whitewater canoeing or kayaking. Obviously, a certain measure of technical skills is required to become proficient in the sport; however, it’s only one component of a bigger picture.
The same applies to organizations. A manager cannot expect to just force his or her ideas and will upon others. While technical skills are important, such as what was learned at business school (e.g., accounting, quantitative methods and marketing), to effectively lead people requires accumulated knowledge and wisdom.
One of the most important things I learned from my canoeing instructors was that while you could learn technical skills fairly quickly, it took years and years to build a knowledge base from your experiences. For example, there have been numerous news stories on young paddlers (typically males) who became technically proficient in handling a canoe or kayak but ran into serious problems when they got in over their heads. They didn’t understand well enough how to read a river or to take the time to map out a route, including identifying hazards (e.g, partially submerged logs). Patience is what’s critical here, and a measure of humbleness knowing that Mother Nature deserves respect.
Unfortunately, each year canoeists and kayakers drown or become paraplegics or quadriplegics when they exceed their technical capabilities. And it’s often the less experienced who end up in these situations. The message my instructors gave their students was to respect the river because it is unforgiving. The same applies to organizations, especially during times of economic stress.In the context of today’s organizational whitewater, the message for new and less experienced leaders is to be humble, watch and listen for the signals, and learn from your experiences. Of particular importance is to practice patience. Do this and you’ll emerge at the other end of the whitewater a better leader and intact.
Photos by Jim Taggart (Penobscot River, Maine).
Click here to download a complimentary copy of Jim’s e-book Becoming a Holistic Leader, 3rd Edition.
""""
Articles from Jim Taggart
View blogFranklin Delano Roosevelt rates as being one of America’s greatest presidents, probably in the top t ...
The human race is an odd species. Adaptive to immediate threats and catastrophes, we as humans have ...
My recent posts explored what it means to be a team, the five levels of teamwork, how to build perfo ...
You may be interested in these jobs
-
Design/drafting Manager
1 day ago
Direct apply
Ovivo Hamilton, Canada**What is the Opportunity? · Joining Ovivo means being part of a global team of innovative and passionate professionals who are committed to preserving water, our planet's most critical resource. It also means combining our efforts and talents towards a more sustainable future - ...
-
Rédacteur/Rédactrice de propositions
2 hours ago
Colliers Drummondville, Canada Regular Full timeOverview · At Colliers Project Leaders, we deliver capital project solutions to fulfill our clients' needs across the built environment. The work we do makes a difference in communities and for the people who live there. We have a passion for it. · Our commitment to realizing o ...
-
Accounting and Transaction Advisory Director
4 days ago
PwC Toronto, ON, CanadaLine of Service Assurance · Specialism CMAAS (Capital Markets and Accounting Advisory Services) · Management Level Director · Job Description & Summary The Capital Markets Accounting Advisory Services team ("CMAAS") at PwC is a team committed to supporting clients through momen ...
Comments
Jim Taggart
6 years ago #1
Henry Mintzberg is a keen observer of managerial leadership, and one of the few knowledgeable experts with solid empirical research under his belt.