The 5 Most Critical Recruitment Tactics

The 5 Most Critical Recruitment Tactics


By Mark Stephens

I have come to the clear conclusion that there are 5 primary pillars that every business and company recruiter should place at the heart of their direct hire recruitment strategy if they want it to consistently succeed.

Believe me when I say that I have looked at a lot of research and recruitment data in the last 10 years and worked closely with over 500 hundred organisations of all shapes and sizes, and there are most definitely direct correlations between those tactics and strategies being deployed by those organisations and individuals that most consistently perform well when it comes to maintaining the best results around the key metrics that define how effective your direct hire strategy really is.

These have obviously changed over the years, as new influences infiltrate the recruitment landscape and human behaviours change, but right now, these are, in my relatively well informed opinion, the key components that I see associated with the most effective recruitment strategies being deployed right now.

I am going to list them here at the start of this article so that you understand right from the off what we are dealing with and decide if this article is for you.

I will then explore why each of them are so critical to maintaining consistent success and delivering improvements, and then provide insights into what you can do about it.

What I will aim to do throughout this article is to outline why each of these items is so critical in pursuit of the best results and provide practical advice and ideas on how to address and deploy each topic effectively.

Choosing the correct channels to attract applicants

I am starting with this topic, because it is so fundamentally important to an effective direct hire and talent attraction strategy and yet surprisingly it gets very little coverage or airtime in the recruitment press.

Think about it, if the job advert is not placed in the correct channels then those prospective applicants, even those that are actively looking, are not going to find you.

Because there is such a diverse range of media channels available to consider advertising your jobs on, it can be difficult to know which is most likely to work for you and will give you the best value for money.

To execute an effective media buying strategy, you must do your homework and that begins by first understanding the behaviours of the job searching candidates that you want to engage with.

Extensive research on this topic has concluded that there are two primary elements over and above anything else that determine which channels are most likely to succeed and that should influence your media buying decisions.

1/ Volume of relevant visitor traffic within the channel

2/ The media channels that are performing best for thee specific role you are recruiting for within major search engines; specifically Google.

Neither of these should come as a shock, but when was the last time that you actually researched the demographics and relevant visitor data of the niche board you are considering before posting a job onto it, or ran a search on Google to identify which channel was performing best for that specific job title and location?

Well what is most shocking is that statistically over 90% of you don’t do any or extremely little due diligence before making your media buying decisions.

Depending on whose data you are looking at, somewhere between 70-80% of all job related searches start in Google, so this represents a very good starting point for channel selection.

If you are going to adopt this strategy, then you need to consider doing this each and every time that you are recruiting for a challenging or difficult to fill role. However, because a multi-channel approach, covering several of the best channel options is recommended, this could seriously push the price of advertising up.

The solution to this might be to find a multi-media reseller, as a starting point, and for the price of a couple of job boards, you can look to get your job advert onto all the leading job advertising channels, social media and aggregators for the same price.

This will potentially get your job advertised across all the most visited media channels and give you exceptional value for money, especially when compared to buying directly from each job board.

Optimising application and retention rates

There are key metrics that can be monitored at each stage of the recruitment lifecycle, that should be monitored closely and used to establish the effectiveness of your strategy at each specific stage and act as a guide to optimising outcomes.

During the talent attraction stages there are two key objectives that I wish to focus on.

  • Increasing visibility and applicant traffic to your job advert within each channel
  • Convert more views of your job advert into actual applications


All search engines have a programmed algorithm to determine what appears at the top of page one of results and what appears last. On the majority of job advertising media by appearing on page one of results you will generate up to four times as many views of prospective candidates than you would if your job advert appeared on page two.

There is also a direct correlation between the quality and relevance of candidates dropping out of the job search at the bottom of the first page of results, emphasising the importance of applying keyword optimisation techniques.

Once a candidate has found your job, the objective turns to converting the view into an actual application and this metric can be used to establish the quality of the copywriting and the effectiveness of your job adverts.

It is the combination of structure, style, tone and of course the strength of the proposition, that will determine whether your job advert is successful in turning views into genuine prospects.

Enhancing the candidate experience

Let’s assume that you posted your job advert on the right channels and have not only been found, but that you have successfully persuaded a number of suitable candidates to apply for your vacancy.

What happens next will begin to establish the candidates’ experience of engaging with your brand and this will massively contribute to the successful applicants’ decision to either accept or decline a subsequent offer of employment.

Many companies using recruitment platforms such as ATS systems or HR Recruitment modules use a process called apply by URL. This is the terminology used to describe the process of redirecting a candidate from an advert to another page on a different website. This is usually a careers page on the clients own website.

The undeniable issue with this process is applicant drop off rates that vary between 50-85% and have undoubted correlations between the best quality prospects and those most likely to drop out.

Over 90% of all applications come from people already in work and the vast majority of these people can be described as passive applicants, with low levels of commitment to moving jobs. The demonstrate specific behaviours such as very short search times of less than 20 minutes on average and can easily drop out of the application process when presented with any unexpected tasks, so soon in the process.

Selecting a recruitment system /platform that is able to parse CV’s and profiles straight into the campaign management system from a wide range of the most likely channels is absolutely key in avoiding the major loss of the best quality applicants.

Once the application is received, it’s all about communication, starting with a personalised, yet automated response to each and every applicant, to acknowledge receipt of their application and should also be used as an excellent opportunity to furnish each applicant with additional information about the company, the role and most importantly about the opportunity.

By far the most powerful tool that you have to assist you, ahead of actually speaking to or meeting the applicants is video. Video provides windows into your organisation and culture and is statistically proved to influence attraction and retention rates significantly more than any other communication media.

When delivered effectively, this will ultimately strengthen the interest that applicants have in the role and contribute towards a better retention rate.

As you begin the screening and selection process, it’s all about the quality and delivery of your communications and choosing the right moment to completely humanise the experience.

Humanising the engagement level in both tone of language and ultimately by moving to a telephone, skype or video call as soon as is practical, should be a priority, especially on harder to fill roles.

Finally, the interview process itself needs to strike the right balance between screening and selling the opportunity and to support this an interview strategy should be adopted. This might include a company presentation, a tour of the facility and pre-arranged introductions to certain members of the team.




Choosing the right Recruitment system

Selecting the right recruitment system should not be confused with HR Systems that offer on boarding and employee management features.

The primary objectives of attracting and then managing talent through a screening and selection process up to the point of offer should never drop out of focus and should drive your choice of tech for this purpose.

The right talent attraction and recruitment campaign management system will enable you to operate an intelligent screening and management process that will be time efficient, cost effective and enable you to consistently deliver the best outcomes.

It should help to avoid duplication of effort , reduce time spent on laborious and repetitive administration tasks, help to avoid subconscious bias and enable an effective and positive candidate experience that enhances and protect your brand.

A cloud based service that utilises CV parsing, candidate grading, video profiling, behavioural profiling, integrated application forms and the automation of email and SMS messaging is key.

However, the ultimate test of how good a recruitment talent attraction and campaign management service is, can be determined by whether the vendor is willing to be measured against key recruitment metrics such as application numbers, applicant quality, tie to offer, fulfilment rates and of course overall customer satisfaction.

If a service really is as good as they say it is, then ask them to prove it. If its that good, why wouldn’t they want to share these with you and be measured against them.

Measure to improve

Any business that is committed to delivering a best in class recruitment service must measure key metrics regularly and make plans to improve.

Applicant source, applicant quality, candidate experience, fill rates, time to offer etc can all contribute towards an ongoing commitment to making improvements and will help to keep those people responsible to the recruitment of staff accountable.

It is important to remember that many facets of the recruitment lifecycle are susceptible to change and by measuring key metrics it increases the chance of you identifying both positive and negative changes that effect your recruitment outcomes and respond to them accordingly.

If you are looking to address any of these issues within your business and wanted to grab a 15 minute exploratory conversation with me, just get in touch. I am always happy to help where I can.


More about the author

Mark Stephens has over 20 years of business management experience, across Sales, Marketing, Recruitment and Technology environments. Mark is a recent winner of the Chambers of Commerce award for innovation in business. He is a serial entrepreneur and is the founder of several companies including F10,  Smart Recruit Online and The HR & Recruitment Resource Library.

Mark has established a reputation for his passion and enthusiasm over twenty years working in the recruitment industry, both client and agency side. For the last seven years he has been researching the recruitment landscape from both a technology and people perspective. His insights into market trends are often used and quoted across the industry’s leading publications.

Mark also delivers keynote talks and training to recruitment teams in both public and private sector organisations, on writing better advertising copy, targeting passive candidates and understanding candidate behaviours online.

Connect with Mark Stephens on LinkedIn. 


5 Most viewed articles published by Mark

A new Breed of Recruiter for 2019

Recruiting for Skills and Attitude

Interview no-shows and why they are becoming more common

8 Reasons Recruitment Within the Health & Care Sector isn’t Working

Measuring the cost effectiveness of your advertising channels