Jim Murray

7 years ago · 4 min. reading time · 0 ·

Blogging
>
Jim blog
>
Why 'Calling Bullshit On BeBee Is Something We Should All Get Good At

Why 'Calling Bullshit On BeBee Is Something We Should All Get Good At

to provoke thought and revive the comatoseYou don’t notice it so much here on BeBee, (at least not yet), but on other so called social media sites, there is a preponderance of people who are basically full of shit.
I know this because sometimes I am one of them. LOL. And it sometimes takes one to know one.
These people will bullshit you about, among other things: how busy they are, all the solid, potentially lucrative connections they are making, and how their social media experience is working gangbusters for them in terms of building their business and their brand.
All kinds of stuff that is, according to the 80/20 Differential (shortened down from the bulkier 80/20 Rule of Almost Everything) 80% bullshit. I know it. You know it. And worse of all they know it too. And yet there they are dishing it out like Red Bull samples at a rock concert.
So there’s a big collective bullshit call to all the LIONS, multi level marketers, Nigerian Princes, rich African widows, Pacific Rim companies wanting me to sell steel for them and famale ex-army officers who just want to marry me and live happily ever after.
You Can’t Bullshit A Bullshitter

I used to bullshit people when I was in the advertising agency business. I mean that business is hard core into the bullshit, even back in the seventies and eighties.
We were always trying to find some sort of weasel that would allow us to make an outrageous claim about a product or service. We were always trying to get permission to use words like ‘All Natural Ingredients' or ‘100% Pure’ or ‘Organic’.
This was even before it became all the rage to be organic or holistic or whatever new age bullshit term you want to use.
I’m not saying we used to do it all the time. In fact, once I got to DMB&B and worked on a lot of Procter and Gamble, Hunt Wesson and Mars business, we didn’t really have to bullshit at all.
Why? Because these people were smart marketers and knew that bullshitting their customers was really a component of under-delivering to them, and that that would piss them off. So they would take the time to build a genuine competitive advantage into their products.
This meant we didn’t have to create any marginal or outright false claims and feel like con artists all the time we were doing it.

Some Things Never Change

I see a lot of terrible advertising these days being done by creative people who are trying too hard to keep their crazy clients happy instead of doing the right thing for their brands.
What they don’t realize is that consumers are nowhere near as stupid and gullible as they would like to think they are.
Oh sure they have their quirks and failings. Look at all the fairly smart people who are supporting Trump’s bid for the presidency in the US. Talk about a collective, their businesses and or their families, they have highly developed bullshit antennae.
I also see a lot of companies trying to bullshit people too.
Take the Volkswagon scandal. Bullshitting the public about emissions and fuel mileage is, now and on into the indefinite future, costing them billions.
This crap not has not only adversely affected their share price, but has also done irreparable damage to all the good will their brands have taken years to build. And it’s not going away any time soon. There are too many jackals in suits to ever let that happen.

Don’t Do The Crime If You Can’t Do The Time

Any time you try to bullshit people, at least 80% of the time, you can count on it blowing up in your face. Or even, in some cases, blowing your head right off.
So look before you leap, because it’s not just bloggers like me who will call you on your bullshit, These days it’s more likely to be your clients or your clients’ customers.

I Used To Be A World Class Bullshitter…But Things Have Changed.

When I started really working for myself, either in partnerships with other creative people or with my own accounts, I realized that the world of communications had become infested with people who didn’t really have the slightest idea what they were doing.
They were just bullshitting their way through campaigns and web sites and collateral material and blog posts without any idea where they were taking their brands.
I know this because one time I did an LI post on communications strategy and offered to email people the strategy document I use with my clients. Even in my small LI universe got over 200 requests and each one of them was from someone who was an account exec, account director or marketing manager.
These peoples’ jobs are supposed to be writing strategies. But the majority of them who requested my strategy document told they had been fumbling around for quite some time trying to figure out what the important elements of a communication strategy should be.
Hear that enough and you will get this strange feeling in your head like someone has drilled a hole into your skull and is trying to suck out some of your brain matter.

We All Need To Be Bullshit Cops

548b57cc.jpgHere on BeBee or wherever you happen to pitch your social media tent, it’s important to always be mindful of the bullshit you see there and call people on it.
You don’t have to scream and shout and you don’t even have to do it publicly, but it is important.
I closed down my original Facebook account because the bullshit level had gotten out of control and the thought occurred to me that maybe I could have done something about it earlier instead of just letting it happen.
Bullshit is like that. If people do it well then sometimes it can trick you.
I take my cues from my friend Phil Friedman who has the best bullshit radar of anyone I know. And he is diplomatic and articulate enough to point it out without angering people. (most of the time).  Now that’s a skill and a half.
My experience with Javier and his team lead me to believe that they do not want their site to become polluted in the way LinkedIn and Facebook have become. So you can genuinely feel free to inform them of anything that pops up here that looks like bullshit.
And Finally....

I don’t have a big wrap up here or cogent points of advice. If you have read this far then you get the point.
I honestly feel like beBee is a fresh start for a lot of us in a number of ways. I just want to do what I can to keep this site as bullshit free as possible. And I hope you do too.

68cc84f0.png

All my profile and contact information can be accessed here
https://www.bebee.com/producer/@jim-murray/this-post-is-my-about-page

All content and images copyright 2016 Jim Murray and a pretty waitress. All rights reserved.



"""
Comments

Phil Friedman

7 years ago #20

#36
Yes, Jim Murby ( Jim Murray ), I have to spell it out each time letter by letter. Or else, copy and paste it.

Jim Murray

7 years ago #19

#35
Hey Phil, you can have it because you're probably the only one who can spell it.

Phil Friedman

7 years ago #18

#33
Sorry, Milos Djukic. Cheers ... seriously!

Jim Murray

7 years ago #17

#30
Thanks Paul. I wasn't intending to put down advertising per se. Glad to see you are in agreement with my basic premise. Have fun in England. I'm sure it will still be Merry Olde no matter what.

Paul Walters

7 years ago #16

As always Jim Murray a great post!! Having spent most of my life in the advertising business with both the multi nationals and latterly with my own agency ( which I sold to a multi national where I once worked !) BS is inherent in advertising no matter how you cut it. " makes clothes whiter' ' tastes like heaven' etc etc etc . Consumers on the whole can see through this BS although in the last decade reaching 18 - 25 year olds has become more and more difficult as they have finely attuned BS radars . If BS and outrageous claims pop up on this site there are enough intelligent writers and readers to go directly to the comment section and point out the flaws . Ditto with plagiarism which I have come across fairly frequently (and I am a relatively new convert to beBEE) . BS will always be with us and the best producers are the ad guys...sad but true. I have a book coming out next year entitled " The Lying Game' which is semi autobiographical and is a humourous look at the industry . Thanks for making me have an early morning rant! Oh by the way I am in the UK for a couple of weeks looking at the Brexit ad campaign on the "leave' vote. Now there was a campaign that told blatant lies across every media including digital on line sites FB etc . The thing that stings is , it worked!!!! Sad but true.

Phil Friedman

7 years ago #15

#27
- That the parameters of insipid are in the eye of the beholder. As to a definition of the term:"Insipidipity", that is another matter, for I claim to have coined it. Insipidipity is the property of being bland, politically correct, and social media safe. Insipidipity seeks to generate meaningless positive strokes and pats on the back, while avoiding any and all intellectual stimulation that might result in the receiving of a critical comment. Insipidipity consists not only of posts, both short and long, but of comments as well, all constructed to "build a personal brand", without really saying anything of substance, or merit, unless it's about things that the author knows little or nothing, for example, advice on how to revise your resume from someone who has held but a job or two in her or his entire life, or pronouncements about entrepreneurship from persons who have never started a real company, let alone run one..

Phil Friedman

7 years ago #14

@ Jim Murray - I keep coming back to this post, which I suppose might tell people something about me. However, I am driven to make another point: When we decide to call out some bit of bullshit, we should make sure that we've taken the time to actually read that which we're criticizing. I can't count the number of times I've been criticized by people, especially our corps of pet trolls, who haven't read or understood what I've written. But are arguing against some phantom protagonist. Meaning their remarks are a lot of sound and fury, signifying nada. That is, their comments are bullshit. Cheers!

Jim Murray

7 years ago #13

#6
Aren't we all...from time to time. At least according to our pet trolls.

Graham🐝 Edwards

7 years ago #12

Thanks Jim Murray for this post. I will work hard to keep my bullshit meter calibrated.

don kerr

7 years ago #11

#21
D'accord. They irritate the hell out of me though but you've sparked my interest - there are content generating apps? You are quickly becoming my social media sensei Phil Friedman

Phil Friedman

7 years ago #10

#20
Don Kerr, I am personally less concerned with fakers and scammers, who are infinitely fewer in number than the generators of Inspidipity, who among other things, are now using content generating app to write an overwhelming amount of... space-filling nothing. Cheers!

don kerr

7 years ago #9

Ah that's just bullshit Jim Murray and others of the leadership team remain aware and in touch we're likely to see bullshit reined in. Ultimately though you are correct - it is up to each bee to police this and ensure we don't end up swimming a cesspool of scammers and fakers.

Phil Friedman

7 years ago #8

#14
@Dale Masters - if you're claim to being a major bull chip buster on social media were true, you would not have time to do anything else, including eat. So, may I suggest that there are many who call out BS when it is warranted, and that keeping beBee clear of it will involve a community effort. And it will involve more than simply combative comments. Cheers!

Phil Friedman

7 years ago #7

Jim Murray, in the absence of editorial control -- which yech! is what caused all the problems on LI and elsewhere -- the only way to keep the bull chip count down is for all of us to "mute" the consistent purveyors of such. If enough beBees do that, pretty soon those purveyors of bull chips will be talking only to themselves. That, plus the rest of us have to refrain from falling into posting Insipidipity. Cheers!

Larry Boyer

7 years ago #6

I hope it stays that way, but when people are involved how are you going to stop? Hopefully it'll get better once we get past the US elections.

Jim Murray

7 years ago #5

#8
Hey....don't make me come down there.

Jim Murray

7 years ago #4

#2
Thanks . There's no feeling quite like the feeling of being appreciated.

Phil Friedman

7 years ago #3

Yes, Jim Murray, sometimes, very occasionally, you are indeed among them Not-LOL. :-)

Jim Murray

7 years ago #2

#2
Thanks Pam...there's

Kevin Pashuk

7 years ago #1

Don't worry Jim Murray (Hey! That rhymes!) I have my Male Bovine Fecal Matter Detector all charged up and ready. (https://www.bebee.com/producer/@kevin-pashuk/male-bovine-fecal-matter) If we call out bullshit (respectfully of course), then we can help ensure beBee's quality doesn't degrade into the pit of mediocrity.

Articles from Jim Murray

View blog
1 year ago · 4 min. reading time

I · can’t speak for all writers, because I’m only this one and that’s really all the opinion I am en ...

1 year ago · 2 min. reading time

Whenever I write anything about America I have to take into account that it is actually two countrie ...

1 year ago · 2 min. reading time

Two years ago I returned home from a four month ordeal that included major spinal surgery, that took ...

Related professionals

You may be interested in these jobs

  • Control Tech

    1st Year Electrical Apprentice

    Found in: beBee S2 CA - 2 weeks ago


    Control Tech Dawson Creek, Canada Full time

    Job Brief: · The 1st Year Electrical Apprentice field technician will work with and learn from Journeyman Electricians and other apprentices. The Apprentice will be shown practical skills and learn to test, calibrate, install, repair, and inspect manufacturing equipment and monit ...

  • Bujold Custom Homes

    carpenter

    Found in: Talent CA 2 C2 - 1 day ago


    Bujold Custom Homes Renfrew, Canada

    Education: Other trades certificate or diploma · Experience: 1 year to less than 2 years · or equivalent experience · Work setting · New residential home building · Tasks · Prepare estimates of labour and/or material costs · Read and interpret blueprints, drawings and sketches to ...

  • Tetra Tech

    Technicien(ne) concepteur(trice) – Génie civil

    Found in: Talent CA C2 - 6 days ago


    Tetra Tech Gaspé, Canada Permanent

    Propulsez votre carrière chez Tetra Tech Chef de file mondial en services de génie-conseil et ingénierie, nous offrons une culture d'entreprise conviviale et inclusive aux membres de notre belle équipe, afin de les aider à s'accomplir. · Chez Tetra Tech, nos gens, c'est notre for ...